The Siegel Superman decision
UPDATES: For more, check out my initial FAQ and my subsequent series on the case over at Blog@Newsarama.
This is the big one. The judge has issued a ruling in the case regarding the Siegel family's rights in Superman. It doesn't resolve all the issues--for example, this does not address the Superboy issue, which is a separate case. However, it does award the heirs copyright in the Superman material in Action Comics number 1 (the judge uses the term "Vol. 1", but that's only a reference to the first issue.).
Here's the stirring conclusion:
After seventy years, Jerome Siegel’s heirs regain what he granted so long ago – the copyright in the Superman material that was published in Action Comics Vol. 1. What remains is an apportionment of profits, guided in some measure by the rulings contained in this Order, and a trial on whether to include the profits generated by DC Comics’ corporate sibling’s exploitation of the Superman copyright.
If you read the opinion, you'll note a number of references to the treatise on copyright written by William Patry. Patry, now Google's legal counsel, offers a crisp write-up of the opinion on his blog, along with an homage to Jewish comic book creators of the golden age. The key takeaway from a legal perspective is the following:
The dramatic sounding nature of the final paragraph of the opinion has to be put in context though. The opinion doesn’t cover Shuster’s interests, which are not subject to Section 304(c) termination, but rather a future 304(d) termination. Nor does the opinion reach the work for hire question for anything after the (justly famous and important) Action Comics Vol. 1 published on April 18, 1938 – the collateral estoppel applied on work for hire only covers Action Comics Vol. 1. Finally, there are very thorny issues of apportionment. All of these issues are likely to be the subject of subsequent motions and possibly trial.
Still, despite its limited scope and remaining unfinished details, this is a historic ruling rich with symbolic significance. And in a poignant coincidence, the judge issued his order on the same day that Grant Morrison's homage to Siegel and Shuster in All Star Superman #10 hit the stands.
Jeff,
Great post! Were you following this because of the historic legal decision or because you are a comic book fan as well?
Cheers
JL Carvalho
Founder
The Canadian Social Entrepreneurship Foundation
www.csef.ca
"How many miles away is a social entrepreneur from you?"
More than latter than the former, really--I've been reading comics for decades and have followed comics cases for almost as long.
The Siegel case is one that has interesting connections to social entrepreneurship, particularly in regard to corporate social responsibility and more generally corporate ethics. I will probably chat more about that soon.
And in answer to the question in your sig, here I don't think you can walk half a block without tripping over one--they're everywhere!
My favorite sentence in the decision: "The Court thus concludes that defendants may continue to exploit the image of a person with extraordinary strength who wears a black and white leotard and cape."
It's also worth mentioning that if you want a digital copy of Action Comics #1 in its entirety (well, all the parts by Siegel and Shuster), you can get one by downloading this decision.
Good post….thanks for sharing..
Interesting one. From this post I have found some links with our living world. The story of Superman is so much old and I thought that the inventor of this magical platform definitely passed away. But I was wrong, thanks for sharing.
As a active member of a renowned SEO Company I visit many sites, but did not get such giant news. Can you give me the picture of the current situation of this case?
Interesting one. From this post I have found some links with our living world. The story of Superman is so much old and I thought that the inventor of this magical platform definitely passed away. But I was wrong, thanks for sharing.
As a active member of a renowned SEO Company I visit many sites, but did not get such giant news. Can you give me the picture of the current situation of this case?
Budget SEO This had a little of everything; comedy and drama both. I'll be stopping by here more often :D
Budget SEO This had a little of everything; comedy and drama both. I'll be stopping by here more often :D
Oh! that's sounds interesting my friend. As I have said before that I thought no one is alive connected with the great comics, but I was wrong. I have shared your post with my friends and they also find it interesting. thanks for giving such great topic to discuss. Oh! just forgot to tell you that recently have joined a renowned car paint repair service company, it offers their services in a very cheap rate.
By the way thanks again for sharing....
Trying to keep who owns what and who has the rights to what can become a big, foggy mess sometimes. I think on this one, though, it's pretty darn clear. What were they thinking?
Hi,
I have already looked at Blog@Newsarama, it sounds interesting. I have tried to dispatch a comment on this post, but unfortunately I was failed. Think it was a technical fault, hope will be able soon. Here I must say you have done a good research on Comic World News.
Actually I have connection with a renowned debt settlement Charlotte attorney. So I was searching some unique cases, then I found yours and like it. Thanks for sharing...
Hi,
I have already looked at Blog@Newsarama, it sounds interesting. I have tried to dispatch a comment on this post, but unfortunately I was failed. Think it was a technical fault, hope will be able soon. Here I must say you have done a good research on Comic World News.
Actually I have connection with a renowned debt settlement Charlotte attorney. So I was searching some unique cases, then I found yours and like it. Thanks for sharing...
I have already mentioned that have faced some technical problem while try to comment on Blog@Newsarama, by the way have you got any recent news on that topic. Actually I am very much interested to write a blog on that topic and definitely your post will inspire me a lot.
SEO Services
hey..... the judge gave the good justice for the Siegel family's rights in Superman....... if you are the regular fan of superman then you know what is right....
Thanks for the article..
funny jokes
hey, it jsut looks great.. very good work! Serverreinigung
Thanks for sharing.. It looks very nice..
SEO Services
Thanks for sharing.. It looks very nice.
Remember personal info?
DELL Studio XPS 16, Studio XPS 1640 Laptop Battery
Thanks for sharing.. It looks very nice..
by the way have you got any recent news on that topic. Actually I am very much interested to write a blog on that topic and definitely your post will inspire me a lot.
I can not express my feeling
I am visiting this site first time. This article has nice information.
It is nice to read this story. Or better to say news. Intersting to know and like to know about the current situation.
I have another shocking news - An internet marketing consultant is offering free consultancy.
I suggest you to make a website with such shocking news, but before going for any website design company, you must consult with a consultant.
I have recently got that information that a site offering pure life insurance quotes and have also found a good medical tourism agency, mainly stands for bonding patients to quality medical surgery facilities overseas. Good to know. Hope it will help you.
Now you can grab rabbit rampant in a very cheap rate. Just go for it...
That is going to be some payout for Superman. wonder if he will get percentage of movie and TV superman revenue. It just goes to show you that steady is the race can be won by the tortoise. Oh, and all the translated language versions abroad.
The use of bird feeders has been claimed to cause environmental problems; some of these were highlighted in a front-page article in The Wall Street Journal.
Interesting one. From this post I have found some links with our living world. The story of Superman is so much old and I thought that the inventor of this magical platform definitely passed away. But I was wrong, thanks for sharing.
organic">http://www.saferbrand.com">organic fertilizer
Jerome Siegelâ deserves it. I am glad that they where granted copyright in the Superman material that was published in Action Comics Vol. 1.Acne Treatment
Good work done as always, thank you and keep up the great work.
Thank you so much for taking care to share this one, I am more than happy.
Thanks for sharing your great post,wish you have a nice day,happy every day!You are looking at the new jewelry version of the Double Eagle Co-Axial Chronograph from Replica omega.Nice piece of information and you got very impressive writing skills.
It is nice to read this story. Or better to say news. Intersting to know and like to know about the current situation.
Tiresias washttp://www.ed-hardy-uk.com/ed-hardy-hats-c-25.html > ed hard hats
We are a group of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community. Your blog provided us valuable information to work on.You have done a marvellous job!
http://www.watchestoo.com/
Quite a ruling and still important today.
hi thanks for great share.
I can't wait for the Nolan Bros Superman reboot Bathroom Furniture
But they better finish off the batman story Ark first
Copyright law can be quite tricky.
superman....
Now a day we are living in era of computer. When we talk about the computer, we obviously think about internet. And in the net world SEO has took an important place. Search Engine Marketing has now a lead role there. There are many Search Engine Marketing Company in the world.
Now a day we are living in era of computer. When we talk about the computer, we obviously think about internet.By the way we also have to talk about Web Development Company. Now every IT Company has a website.
Now a day we are living in era of computer. When we talk about the computer, we obviously think about internet. And in the net world SEO has took an important place. Now every IT Company has a website and they need Business Website Design, as well as SEO. To do this SEO job they also need a SEO Consultant.
Now a day we are living in era of computer. When we talk about the computer, we obviously think about internet. And in the net world SEO has took an important place. To do this SEO Job they also need a SEO Consultant and a SEO Expert. So this can be assumed that this sector will rule the IT world.
Quite a ruling and still important today.
cheap wicked tickets
cheap lion king tickets
i am glad to read this wonderful post
i am glad to read this wonderful post
cheap lady gaga tickets
cheap james taylor tickets
cheap carole king tickets
To travel fast & for short trip everyone need Cheap Flight. People like to travel with Cheap Holiday Package
it’s very necessary to have a Cheap Holiday Package. But the best Cheap Package
From All Inclusive Vacation. From All Inclusive Package people can get all things at a time.
Package holiday is another option in hand that is useful, for those who like to travel. The Holiday Deals should be good.
Package holiday is another option in hand that is useful, for those who like to travel. The Holiday Deals should be good.
This should be like All Inclusive Holiday, so that people can afford. Also that is important is the information. The Tourist Information is must to avoid hazards. One must consult with Travel Consultant.
SEO Expert India provides best SEO services Tips. Get professional Seo services from a seo expert India, it provides quality SEO Services. Reliable SEO helping hand for you online business promotion.
it is true what you said above... I tried the same strategy for my site:
san jose allergist
it is true what you said... I will use it for my search engine optimization site.
he son of Jewish immigrants from Lithuania, Siegel was the youngest of six children. His father Mitchell Siegel (née Mikhel Segalovich) was a sign painter who opened a haberdashery and encouraged his son's artistic inclinations. Mitchell died of a heart attack brought on by the robbery of his store, when Jerry was in junior high school. Siegel was a fan of movies, comic strips, and especially science fiction pulp magazines. He became active in what would become known as fandom, corresponding with other science fiction fans, including the young future author Jack Williamson. In 1929, Siegel published what might have been the first SF fanzine, Cosmic Stories, which he produced with a manual typewriter and advertised in the classified section of Science Wonder Stories. He published several other booklets over the next few years.By the way if you have need any helps of seo expert UK for solving seo problem then you may contact at Bidyut Bikash Dhar who also offers Link Building Consulting Services in London, UK. If you are searching keywords like SEO consultant UK, SEO expert UK, Link building UK, Local SEO UK, UK SEO, SEO UK, London SEO, SEO London, SEO company London, SEO consultant London, SEO agency London, web London, UK consultant, UK SEO consultant, SEO services London, SEO services UK, SEO Consulting then call us now at +44.2032866561.But executive staffing can be a lead source for good number of executive jobs. And finding a company that can successfully places people with your kind of skills will be key to success. Basically what kind of position they fill or what types of openings they have can give one an idea of whether it’s worth your time to apply. google adwords is basically Google which allows targeting 10 million people within 10 minutes so how much more impressive a form of advertising can there be. However, success for any business depends on the proper advertisement of a campaign.
Siegel in 1975 launched a public-relations campaign to protest DC Comics' treatment of him and Shuster; ultimately Warner Communications, DC's parent company, awarded Siegel and Shuster $20,000 a year each for the rest of their lives and guaranteed that all comics, TV episodes (which would eventually include the popular Smallville show), films, and (later) video games starring Superman would be required to credit Superman was "created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster."By the way best dating sites or Internet dating is a dating system which allows individuals, couples and groups to make contact and communicate with each other over the Internet, usually with the objective of developing a personal, romantic or sexual relationship. Online dating services usually provide un moderated matchmaking over the Internet, through the use of personal computers or cell phones. But best online poker is a great place to try one’s luck. You do not have to pay the last money. It becomes really interesting when you play online poker for fun and not to earn money. Many have got a passion to play online casino games. But before you begin to play online casino you need to have proper knowledge about online casino poker strategies.
On March 23, 2006, federal judge Ronald S. W. Lew issued a summary judgment ruling that the Siegel heirs had the right to revoke their copyright assignment to Superboy and had successfully reclaimed the rights as of November 17, 2004. Warner Bros. and DC Comics replied that they "respectfully disagree" with the ruling and will seek review. Warner Bros. and DC Comics filed a motion for reconsideration of Judge Lew's ruling in January 2007. On July 27, 2007, federal judge Larson (who had replaced Lew upon his taking "senior status") issued a ruling reversing Judge Lew's ruling that the Siegel heirs had reclaimed the rights to Superboy.If you have need any helps of Seo Services then you may contact at Professional SEO company in the London, UK. Use our SEO services offers to rank your website into top 10 positions on Google, MSN, Yahoo and other search engines. And Epos Software , pos software, epos system, pos system, restaurant pos software, hotel software, restaurant pos, point of sale, Membership Software available with very affordable price rates. Best choice for choice for pos restaurant software, restaurant management software, restaurant pos software worldwide. Leading IT Recruitment Agency
based in London, the UK which recruits IT skilled peoples throughout London. Register now at www.recruitmentagency.net
Really like this website, this really helps and very useful.
That is quite an amazing decision. Big fan of superman though.
I wouldn't necessarily say the society was uncivil. Maybe they liked video games
It still remains a mystery why Jesus allows that.
nice post keep posting like this
wicked orlando
wicked chicago
wicked tucson
wicked appleton
wicked eugene
wicked spokane
wicked washington
wicked kalamazoo
wicked boise
wicked indianapolis
wicked columbus
wicked minneapolis
wicked memphis
wicked omaha
wicked madison
wicked albuquerque
wicked little rock
wicked fresno
wicked tulsa
web design company india is a reliable source for best qualitative web design services. It stands for providing affordable web design services, a renowned name in the field of web design company.
This comic brings back so many memories of when I was child and I use to read these magazines. They are always a good read! Keep it up!
Jo
Email Marketing Software
This is a very interesting post.... We can know about the legal references as well as the historical background. For more you can visit my website www.dreamwebsolution.com
Thanks
We are a group of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community. Your blog provided us valuable information to work on.You have done a marvellous job! Cheap San Francisco Giants Tickets
Nice information, for sure this idea could be good to many websites.
Its an excellent post. Really enjoyed reading it. Good luck.
Generic drug list
Buy Viagra Super Active online
Buy Generic Zithromax online
Buy Generic Viagra online
Buy Generic Propecia online
Buy Cialis Super Active online
Buy Generic Lexapro online
Buy Generic Cialis online
Buy Generic Accutane online
Buy Generic Levitra online
Buy Generic Lasix online
Buy Generic Xenical online
Medicines and Treatment
Treatment with combinations of drugs
by the way have you got any recent news on that topic. Actually I am very much interested to write a blog on that topic and definitely your post will inspire me a lot.
Dvdrip Movies
thanks for great post.
web design company india is a reliable source for best qualitative web design services. It stands for providing affordable web design services, a renowned name in the field of web design company.
Seo Company India provides best SEO services. Get professional Seo services from a seo company India, it provides quality seo services india. Reliable SEO helping hand for you online business promotion.
Seo Company India provides best SEO services. Get professional Seo services from a seo company India, it provides quality seo services india. Reliable SEO helping hand for you online business promotion.
The dramatic sounding nature of the final paragraph of the opinion has to be put in context though. The opinion doesn’t cover Shuster’s interests, which are not subject to Section 304(c) termination, but rather a future 304(d) termination. cheap wicked tickets
This is a perfect time to say that you affected me with your perfect story related to this good post. Hair Extensions Specialist
I am very interested in your article, I think your articles are so interesting that I need more information, go is berkaya and I will always support you. I say many thanks to you. Marks and Spencer Money | Hair Extensions Specialist
Your article is written very content, All of the projects look great! Keep the Ball Rolling. Thanks!
Nice stuff to read, impressed very much and please keep me updating in future as well .Thanks for this.........