New Siegel case briefs yield free comics & law crack

| | | Comments (1)

So work commitments have you stuck at home while every one else who reads comics--and given the size of today's comics buying market, I mean that literally--is out gallivanting at the San Diego Comic Con. What's there to do except wallow in self-pity and stay late filing TPS reports?

I'll tell ya what, grasshopper. Y'see, thanks to good folks in the Siegel case, you now have a chance to spend this weekend living out the Con's charitable purpose by getting a comics education right here at your computer screen.

The latest briefs from both sides are available, with the Siegels and DC taking their best shot at legal questions arising from the Siegels' copyright interest in the Superman material in Action Comics 1. If the briefs were just dueling legal analysis, I might have just posted the links with a just a promise to write more about it later once my own deadlines are met, but there's more.

A lot more.

  • Web pages that sell Superman stuff (OK, not so exciting there, but look what's next . . . )
  • Free comics entered as exhibits by DC to illustrate its legal points.

There are also complete copies of Superman movies, but alas, these have been sealed so as not to be made available for free online as government exhibits.

OK, so it's not quite the Con, but if you & your SO read this stuff while dressed up as Wolverine & Slave Girl Leia it can be a reasonable substitute.


200807221452.jpg

1 Comments

mgrabois Author Profile Page said:

Jeff - what happens on Aug. 11th? All of the documents refer to some other meeting with the judge on that date.

I haven't plowed through the briefs yet, but I have read the three Declarations. I was very impressed with Mark Evanier's testimony, and he almost had me convinced that Superboy belongs to the Siegels, but I just can't get past the whole "Superman as a boy" thing: how can that not be derivative? Regardless of all the original things Siegel and Shuster brought, I feel that because they spun out of "Superman as a boy", it's all derivative.

The copies of the 1939 and 1947 documents were pretty interesting, though.

Of course, as a layman, I don't have to consider case law, or prepare 80-Page Giant briefs (why are both 80 pages, by the way? Is that some rule?), I can just read things (or not) and bitch about them on the internet.

Leave a comment

About

  • Jeff Trexler
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • BofG

Tag Cloud

Sign In

www.flickr.com
This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from trexfiles23. Make your own badge here.

December 2008

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31